Barbara Walsh: Maine’s struggles with domestic violence and child abuse worsened last summer

Our project, “Unsafe Homes: Children in Peril,” put a spotlight on the issue. A legislative advocate for children is optimistic about pending reforms.
Senator Bill Diamond poses for a photo in his office while sitting at his desk with a poster for Walk a Mile in Their Shoes pulled up on the computer screen.
State Sen. Bill Diamond (D-Windham) has pushed for reforms to the child welfare agency for the past 20 years. To remember the children who have died in recent years due to neglect or abuse, Diamond created an event called “Walk a Mile in Their Shoes” where he and other lawmakers held rallies in six Maine communities where children died in unsafe homes. Photo by Garrick Hoffman.

Maddox Williams. Hailey Goding. Sylus Melvin. Baby Harding.

Two Maine toddlers and two babies died in their homes last summer.

A 6-week-old infant was shaken to death. A month-old baby died due to injuries police have not yet revealed. A 3-year-old was beaten to death. Another 3-year-old overdosed on fentanyl. Parents have been charged with murder in all four cases.

The Maine Monitor reported on these heartbreaking deaths in its series “Unsafe Homes: Children in Peril.”

The unusually high number of child homicides prompted outrage and concern about Maine’s child protective services, which had contact with most of the families prior to the deaths.

An independent review by Casey Family Services, a national child welfare research organization, recommended in October that Maine’s Department of Health and Human Services improve its coordination and communication with law enforcement, hospitals and social workers during child abuse or neglect cases.

Though Health and Human Services Commissioner Jeanne Lambrew said her agency is committed to making changes and learning from the “tragic deaths,” state senator Bill Diamond (D-Windham) criticized the Casey Family’s report. A longtime child advocate, Diamond said it did little to address DHHS’s systemic problems that fail to protect children.

Without changing the culture and protocols at DHHS, Diamond fears more children will perish in their homes like those who died this past summer.

“It’s important to make sure these children are never forgotten,” Diamond said.  “And to keep the spotlight on their memories and on the systemic failures that contributed to their deaths.”

Diamond said he is constantly reminded about Maddox Williams, Hailey Goding, Sylus Melvin and Baby Harding.

“I can’t go anywhere without someone bringing up their deaths,” Diamond said. “The public is demanding changes.”

Diamond is optimistic that nine new bills to be considered in the upcoming legislative session will offer more transparency and accountability in the child welfare system.

One of the bills proposes that the Government Oversight Committee receive reports on the child protective services every three months instead of only when “something bad happens,” said Diamond, who drafted two of the bills.

Other bills include increasing funding for the Child Welfare Ombudsman’s office, which reviews concerns and complaints about abuse and neglect cases, and expediting child homicide cases, which can take up to two years to be tried, Diamond said.

“If these cases can be prioritized and moved up to the front of the line, we can learn about the failures in the system and make the changes that need to be made sooner,” Diamond said.

Readers can explore The Maine Monitor’s original series, Unsafe Homes: Children in Peril.


Barbara A. Walsh

Barbara A. Walsh is a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist who has worked for newspapers in Ireland, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Florida. While working at the Lawrence Eagle-Tribune, Walsh reported on first-degree killer William Horton Jr. and Massachusetts’ flawed prison-furlough system. The series changed in-state sentencing and furlough laws and won a 1988 Pulitzer Prize. During her career at the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram, Barbara wrote in-depth series on several social issues in Maine. Many of her stories changed laws and earned national, state and regional awards.
Previous Post
An illustration of four overworked attorneys, as well as an inmate locked in a jail cell.

Samantha Hogan: A year later, Maine still last state without public defenders

Next Post
Mary Freeman, wearing a head lamp, smiles while looking at a piece of tourmaline

Kate Cough: Lithium find prompts landowners to search for Earth-friendly solution

The Maine Monitor has five newsletters to keep you informed about Maine.