Hazel Finch Labs is a proud supporter of The Maine Monitor.

News This is a news story based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.

MSAD 58 pauses decisions on school closures ahead of Nov. 3 withdrawal votes

Potential exits by Kingfield and Strong could drastically reshape enrollment, state funding, and future facility choices for the district.
the entrance to the Mount Abram High School building.
Mt. Abram High School. Photo by Ben Hanstein.

SALEM TOWNSHIP — The Maine School Administrative District 58 board of directors voted Thursday to support ongoing planning efforts with its architectural firm, marking its final scheduled meeting before Kingfield and Strong vote Nov. 3 on whether to leave MSAD 58.

Oak Point Associates, a Biddeford architecture firm specializing in school design, presented its work on a long-term master plan for district facilities, mirroring a community forum Oct. 6.

Oak Point prepared three options to address the district’s primary challenge: a declining student body and four aging schools with mounting maintenance needs.

Option 1 would close Phillips Elementary School and send prekindergarten through third grade students to Kingfield Elementary School. Fourth through eighth graders would attend Day Mountain Regional Middle School in Strong, while high school students would remain at Mt. Abram High School. Central office staff members would also relocate to Mt. Abram.

Option 2 involves similar consolidation but requires more extensive renovations. Phillips Elementary School would close, moving prekindergarten through fourth grade students to Kingfield Elementary School. The shift would require an addition to the Kingfield building, which would also house the central administrative office. Day Mountain Regional Middle School and Mt. Abram High School would undergo renovations primarily designed to modernize facilities.

Option 3 would close all three community elementary and middle schools and build a new school for prekindergarten through eighth grade on the Mt. Abram High School campus. While this option would be the most expensive up front, officials noted it would be the most efficient long-term solution and offer educational benefits by consolidating staff and students on a single site.

Tyler Barter, an architect with Oak Point, said community feedback has focused heavily on Phillips Elementary School, which would close under all three proposed options.

RELATED STORY:   Architectural firm unveils three options for MSAD 58 schools; all would close Phillips Elementary School

The Phillips Elementary School site poses unique challenges due to its sloping terrain, Barter said, noting that expanding the building without compromising parking, bus access, and overall budget would be difficult.

Board Chair Jessica Cain noted an unused ballfield behind the school, but Barter explained that connecting an addition to that parcel would be complicated. A small expansion toward the front of the building remains possible, he added.

Barter said planners found ways to expand the facility, but noted that “it is certainly not going to be the most economical” approach.

Additionally, while a 2024 assessment by Bureau Veritas, an international testing and inspection firm, found that all district buildings face similar needs over a 20-year period, Phillips Elementary School requires the most immediate repairs.

“This building has some needs that are going to come due very soon,” Barter said. “You’re going to see cracking and materials on the exterior that are starting to look a little bit worse than maybe when Bureau Veritas was here last.”

Kingfield Elementary School is 2,500 square feet larger than Phillips Elementary School, Oak Point planners noted, and the district’s current student population would not fit at the Phillips facility. Kingfield Elementary School is also a single-floor building, which offers distinct advantages for younger students.

While noting that he spoke strictly as an architect rather than a community member, Barter said Option 1 represents the most “low-hanging fruit” for saving the district money and consolidating its elementary students and staff members.

In response to a board member’s question, Barter explained that Mt. Abram High School lacks sufficient space to absorb additional grade levels. While enrollment has declined from its peak, the school still requires a similar number of classrooms to meet academic programming needs. Modern high schools also demand more specialized instructional spaces, such as those dedicated to special education programs.

Combining younger students and high school students in the same facility would also present operational challenges, planners noted.

Board members and Oak Point representatives discussed potential funding pathways for each proposal. Barter said the firm remains too early in the planning process to provide specific cost estimates. However, at a previous meeting, he outlined Option 1 as the least expensive initial investment, Option 2 as more costly, and Option 3 as the most expensive upfront choice.

Administrators and planners emphasized that precise financial comparisons remain difficult. Staffing needs and transportation routes would shift depending on which plan the district selects, and overall costs continue to rise annually.

As an example, Superintendent Laura Columbia noted that district enrollment dropped by 38 students compared to the previous year. The decline resulted in a $300,000 loss in state funding, she said.

An upcoming change to the state’s Essential Programs and Services model further complicates the financial picture.

Most expenses under Option 1 would fund facility repairs that the district must complete over the next few years, Barter said. District buildings, for example, broadly require electrical service upgrades.

“It’s a great opportunity to address roofs, bathroom upgrades, all of those accessibility things that need to happen regardless,” Barter said.

The state’s School Revolving Renovation Fund could serve as one funding source if the district develops a plan, Barter said. That program provides up to $2 million in loans per school building within a five-year period. The program then forgives a percentage of the principal and offers up to a 10-year repayment schedule at zero percent interest.

Meeting participants repeatedly referenced pending withdrawal votes in Kingfield and Strong during the discussion. Either or both towns leaving the district would alter student enrollment, state funding calculations and future facility plans.

Supporters of withdrawal have cited potential debt from facility projects as a primary reason to leave the district this year. MSAD 58 now carries minimal debt, a portion of which departing towns must pay if they separate.

Columbia addressed the bonding debate during Thursday’s meeting, emphasizing that district voters must approve any project financing.

She pointed to the Margaret Chase Smith School in Skowhegan, a consolidated elementary school that raised millions through a fundraising campaign alongside a federal grant.

Barter said Oak Point will continue working with the district regardless of whether towns vote to withdraw after Nov. 3.

“We wanted to give you a really good sense of the opportunities with your whole district currently,” Barter said. “But then, as we move forward and as things start to shake out, we have the ability to help you generate new options based on how things are (after Nov. 3).”

Board members and audience members also discussed the future of Mt. Abram High School, revisiting a key topic from the last board meeting. Responding to public questions, Columbia reiterated her worries that town withdrawals could make it far more difficult to provide education from prekindergarten through 12th grade in the region.

“It’s just math. When we pool our money together, we can weather hardships easier,” Columbia said. “I have really big concerns. I’m trying to say this in a neutral, mathematical way: Any time we go apart from each other, it’s going to be harder for us to be sustainable long term.”

RELATED STORY:   As withdrawal votes near, MSAD 58 officials warn Mt. Abram High School’s future is at risk

One attendee asked the board to vote against closing Kingfield Elementary School and Day Mountain Regional Middle School to reassure voters in those towns that withdrawal is unnecessary.

“One of you, please, have the courage, make a motion, make a guarantee to the Kingfield community that you are not going to talk about closing their school for however many years,” said Elizabeth Marble, a Freeman Township resident and district teacher with children and grandchildren in MSAD 58.

Marble also asked the board to make a similar pledge for Strong Elementary School.

Some directors said the board needs to wait for Nov. 3 to determine next steps, adding that it is premature to support a specific plan.

“I think it’ll drive us all crazy if we do too much right now,” said Darin Schwartz, an MSAD 58 board member from Avon. “After that election and we know what’s going on, then I totally agree that we need to be able to sit down and say, ‘OK, we need to really look at what’s happened based on A, B or C.’”

Cain made a motion for the district to move forward with Oak Point’s plans and continue working with the firm on future planning. The board approved the motion.

At the start of the meeting, Columbia read a statement honoring Natalie Wilcox of Strong, an educational technician who most recently worked at Phillips Elementary School. Wilcox died earlier this month following a long illness. Columbia grew emotional at times as she praised Wilcox, saying district employees and students were lucky to know her.

“Natalie was a wonderful person with a big heart, and her loss will be felt throughout our district,” Columbia said.

The board observed a moment of silence for Wilcox.

Mt. Blue Community Access TV recorded the meeting.


WERU Community Radio is a proud supporter of The Maine Monitor.
Share
headshot of the reporter

Ben Hanstein

Ben Hanstein is a contributor to The Maine Monitor. He lives in Farmington, where he runs a used bookstore and reports on stories that matter to western Maine for Monitor Local, an initiative of The Maine Monitor.

Contact Ben with questions, concerns or story ideas:



Don't Miss These Stories

Total
0
Share